(AI) Bullshit and the Ongoing Bullshit Apocalypse

This page will now be the home page/directory for my posts on (AI) Bullshit and the coming ongoing Bullshit Apocalypse. I am breaking it out of my 1st post, June 28, 2024, on generative AI bullshit, "Bullshit All The Way Down".

Upon reflection, I have expanded the topic to be Bullshit in general. Bullshit in general currently pervades our society. Possibly survivable, but not when multiplied by automation in the form of generative AI.

I am working on a magnum opus, "A Taxonomy of Bullshit". Watch this space.

---

[Updated 2024-11-26 and 2025-02-06]
Updated this post re a totally LOL article from the AWS (Amazon Web Services) team, describing strategies for dealing with LLM "hallucinations" - AKA, LLMs just totally making shit up, AKA, bullshitting.

Now its own post: "Hallucinations? No, Bullshit!".

---

[Updated 2025-01-21]
Here is an article talking about how AI mistakes are different from human mistakes.

---

[Updated 2025-02-09]
New post "Deep Bullshit" - in which I discover Gary Marcus; his discussion of OpenAI's scary Deep Research product; and his coining of the term "Deep Bullshit".

---

[Updated 2025-02-10]
The Naples Daily News Piles On!

This is a normally very low quality information source. Maybe there is hope. Maybe we can forestall the coming Bullshit Apocalypse ... Nah, too much $$$ involved. Capitalism, FTL! :-<

---

[Updated 2025-02-15]
Latest installment: "Hallucinations My Ass!".

---

[Updated 2025-02-17]
Ruminations on why LLMs will never lead to AGI: "CommonSense™".

Meanwhile, looking back through this blog, I was writing about AI in 2004, but not using the "artificial intelligence" tag. I went back and tagged the old posts.

---

[Updated 2025-04-29]
Very interesting article "The Hallucinating ChatGPT Presidency" I shared the post (on Kottke) with the comment, "The Orange Turd is indeed the prophet of the coming Bullshit Apocalypse."

I started to inline it here, it is much better if I create a new post, which I did:

The Orange Turd as an Hallucinating LLM

LOL, I could have named it "A Portrait of the Orange Turd as an Hallucinating LLM"! Should I generally start framing things as "A Portrait of {$person} as a {$role}" when I can?

---

[Updated 2025-04-30]
This article came up today in my rss reader:

Kids should avoid AI companion bots—under force of law, assessment says

Man, I'm trying to get the meme "Bullshit Apocalypse" into the noosphere, I should maybe also add "AI Plague".

---

[Updated 2025-05-16]
Another article from the AWS team on LLM "hallucinations". Not as LOL as their prior one.

Detect hallucinations for RAG-based systems

---

[Updated 2025-05-19]
Gee, I wonder why apartheid fan Leon Skunk's chatbot started working references to South African white genocide into all its answers? Maybe just a little too slanted?

For One Hilarious, Terrifying Day, Elon Musk’s Chatbot Lost Its Mind

---

[Updated 2025-05-20]
The coming Bullshit Apocalypse gathers momentum ...

Chicago Sun-Times Prints AI-Generated Summer Reading List With Books That Don't Exist

---

[Updated 2025-05-29]
LOL, I was afraid my review/summary would be longer than the (short) 8k words book, but it was only 2.6k words, FTW! I R A compression algorithm!

My review/summary of "On Bullshit" by Harry Frankfurt.

---

[Updated 2025-06-03]
I'm really interested in Scientist AI, whose goal is to rein in the bullshit apocalypse! FTW!

Scientist AI, FTW?

---

[Updated 2025-06-04]
Doc Searls links to an article & an online course on AI-based bullshit.

Bullshit Machines

---

[Updated 2025-06-04]
Apple scientists cast serious shade on LLMs, with 2 analyses by Gary Marcus.

The Illusion of Thinking

---

[Updated 2025-06-21]
Reading the Apple article mentioned just above, I am triggered by the total bullshit hype marketoid verbiage.

Thinking vs. Non-thinking

---

[Updated 2025-06-22]
Gary Marcus is, as usual, insightful, & horrifying!

LLMs: Dishonest, unpredictable and potentially dangerous.

---

[Updated 2025-06-25]
Who would have guessed that AI-generated résumés would be problematic?

Employers Are Buried in A.I.-Generated Résumés

---

[Updated 2025-06-26]
I have said that if Facebook promoting posts that made people fearful & angry because that made them the most $$$ was not evil, then I didn't know what was. Maybe even more so for AI companies letting their chatbots help people go crazy?

They asked an AI chatbot questions. The answers sent them spiraling.

---

[Updated 2025-06-27]
Not sure if like the title:

AI Hallucinations: Provably Unsolvable - What Do We Do?

or the subtitle:

AI Hallucinations Are Infinite and Unsolvable

best.

Note, "hallucinations" === "completely incorrect responses & bullshit generated by LLMs", called "hallucinations" to falsely conflate them with human brain activity.

---

[Updated 2025-06-28]
I think world models are definitely a component of my CommonSense™ module. Yet another thing LLMs lack.

LLMs Have 0 World Model - Oops!

---

[Updated 2025-07-02]
If you are in Austin TX, or any other city that allows Tesla Robotaxis, UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHOULD YOU JAYWALK!

Tesla's Robotaxi Revolution!

---

[Updated 2025-07-06]
Bullshit meters, FTW! Folksonomy, FTW!

Bullshit Meters

---

[Updated 2025-07-08]
4 articles, 1 referencing 8 different LLM screw-ups, in 2 days.

Hard To Keep Up

---

[Updated 2025-07-09]
Gee, I wonder where Grok gets its Nazi tendencies?

The Nazi Apple Doesn't Fall Far From the Nazi Tree

---

[Updated 2025-07-11]
Zeynep Tufekci, whose writing I like, talks about the Grok incident today in the New York Times.

Musk’s Chatbot Started Spouting Nazi Propaganda. That’s Not the Scariest Part.

LOL, the headline for the article in the email I get from NYT Opinions was "Another Day, Another Chatbot's Nazi Meltdown".

The 1st line of my post on July 9th started "Another day, another LLM running off the rails."

---

[Updated 2025-07-12]
This almost didn't get included, because this post points to stuff that I think maybe explains what LLMs are, what they are capable of, & how they should be used. They are not generating bullshit, they are generating poetry???

Semiotic Zombies

---

[Updated 2025-07-14]
In which I provide supporting evidence for the term "Semiotic Zombies":

Semiotic Zombies, Part 2

Also, Gary Marcus's latest, and 2 more interesting articles.

---

[Updated 2025-07-16]
This is getting to be a real time sink:

I'm Ready for a Day Off

---

[Updated 2025-07-17]
Seth Godin provides another insightful name for LLMs, & Krugman touches on Leon Skunk's Nazi chatbot & contrasts right-wing crypto with left-wing AI.

The Talking Dog

---

[Updated 2025-07-21]
2 more instances of "{$institution} Overwhelmed by AI-generated Bullshit".

The Bullshit Apocalypse Is Here

---

[Updated 2025-07-24]
Again, I was afraid my review/summary would be longer than the (short) 10.2k words essay, but it was only 2.9k words, FTW! Again, I R succesfully A compression algorithm!

"The Prevalence of Humbug", by Max Black.

---

[Updated 2025-08-01]
In which the discovery of a great new LLM name prompts me to create a table of LLM names, currently at 13 19 instances.

Stocastic Parrots

---

[Updated 2025-08-03]
Wow, LLM-based Agents pretty much suck! They're pretty much ... bullshit!

Agents of Bullshit

---

[Updated 2025-08-04]
It is depressing that this meme is so much better than my Bullshit Apocalypse ...

Slopocalypse Now

---

[Updated 2025-08-08]
Another day, several more instances of LLM idiocy:

I'm Sure ChatGPT-5 Will Be Much, Much Better - Not!

---

[Updated 2025-08-10]
My 1st ever instance of Reviewus Interruptus. There was very little in the way of insight to be gleaned from Augustine of Hippo.

I'm not sure if this is symptomatic of Bullshit Contagion. Maybe Bullshit Fatigue is one of the symptoms.

On Lying

---

[Updated 2025-08-14]
Psychotherapy & counseling: yet another job LLMs will screw up.

Sycophants, Of Course

---

[Updated 2025-08-20]
Lots of good data in the 1st link, the 2nd is just more random LLM bullshit.

Chatbot in a Writing Class

---

[Updated 2025-08-27]
Odd that both posts reference "poison" - completely different types tho.

Pick Your Poison

---

[Updated 2025-08-28]
I like this post. If you can shoot holes in it, please do.

Morality™

---

[Updated 2025-09-09]
My work here may be done.

AI Darwin Awards

---

[Updated 2025-09-23]
Wow, 2 weeks since last addition! My work here may indeed be done.

Workslop

Note, with the investment of $100B into OpenAI by Nvidia, this officially becomes, what, a 2nd order bubble? Nth order bubble? I guess OpenAI will use a bunch of that $100B to buy more Nvidia chips. This is not a Ponzi scheme, what is it, exactly?

This reminds me of my initial rant on cryptocurrency, which was titled with a quote by Vitalik Buterin, Mr. Ethereum:

"DeFi today is a circular speculative economy"
[Note, DeFi === Decentralized Finance: cryptocurrencies, NFTs, coins, etc.]

It is so incredible, the synergies between these 2 still active bubbles. Both incredibly compute-intensive, aka, environmental disasters. And both, apparently, just grifters buying each others crap to keep the grift going. KMN.

---

[Updated 2025-10-02]
An incredibly timely & horrifying horror story by Matthew Kessel at tor.com:

Model Collapse

---

[Updated 2025-10-13]
This story is just so sad. It really makes me want to say, "Fuck LLMs, don't use them for anything. Just kill the whole thing dead now."

"AI" Ruins ... Beer

---

[Updated 2025-10-14]
Note, repeating the description of the prior post. Seriously, LLMs are so tempting to use, but, just like social media, they are killing us! Just Say No!

This story is just so sad. It really makes me want to say, "Fuck LLMs, don't use them for anything. Just kill the whole thing dead now."

Desperate "AI" Companies Pivot To ... Porn, Of Course!

---

[Updated 2025-10-17]
Grrr! Wikipedia is a marvel of the world, a labor of love for 10s of 1000s of volunteer editors.

"AI" Comes for Wikipedia

---

[Updated 2025-10-18]
One really wonders what it will take to make people quit ignoring how unreliable this tech is.

LLMs Have Done Worse

---

[Updated 2025-10-27]
My review/summary is 4.6k words, the source material is 11k words. Oops! Again, I R succesfully A compression algorithm, but not a very good one!

"On Truth", by Harry Frankfurt.

---

[Updated 2025-10-29]
Leave it to Leon Skunk to use an LLM to create a fascist Wikipedia. The bar moves yet lower, this is clearly the cream of the slop!

Grokipedia Lowers the Bar for "AI" Slop

---

[Updated 2025-11-04]
Slop, slop, and more slop! Will we ever be able to clean up this mess?

Slop of the Morning to Ya!

---

[Updated 2025-11-06]
I have no idea which is going to create more chaos: slop or agents.

Race to the Bottom: Fascist Slop, Untrustworthy Agents

---

[Updated 2025-11-07]
Meanwhile, the planet burns ...

Yet another AI-powered security arms race.

Faking Receipts with AI

---

[Updated 2025-11-07]
There is no limit to how low this can go. We're so screwed. Capitalism, FTL!

Some Particularly Toxic Slop

---

[Updated 2025-11-09]
Who cares if it's bullshit if you get to live in your own private reality?

Tell Me They Are Not Bullshit Generators

---

[Updated 2025-11-09]
I haven't seen this elsewhere. Rein in the out-of-control LLMs by requiring licenses.

You Should Need a License

---

[Updated 2025-11-11]
Throughout the history of computing, security has almost always been given short shrift. Given the size of the current bubble, it is getting microscopic shrift.

Security? Meh ...

---

[Updated 2025-11-13]
You should need a license.

Oh Boy, Brain Rot!

---

[Updated 2025-11-17]
A license wouldn't help in these cases.

Defamation by Machine

---

[Updated 2025-11-17 2]
Licensing LLM use is the only way we can possibly stop the ongoing Bullshit Apocalypse.

Another Day, Yet Another System Broken by LLMs

---

[Updated 2025-11-23]
Mental health crises, hospital admissions, deaths.

30, 9, 3

---

[Updated 2025-11-28]
This is getting weird. Poetry is LLM kryptonite???

LLM Kryptonite?

---

[Updated 2025-12-03]
The talking dogs need to be put on a tight leash.

Bringing Out the Worst in People

---

[Updated 2025-12-04]
The Bullshit is wearing me out ...

Bullshit Fatigue

---

[Updated 2025-12-05]
My whining yesterday was rewarded with 2 more relevant posts.

1: Meh, plus Duh; 2: LOL!

---

[Updated 2025-12-08]
Chuck Wendig is back. His latest post is short, I give it Must Read status.

Wendig Doubles Down

---

[Updated 2025-12-09]
Somehow, I don't think "being careful" will help against the Bullshit Apocalypse. The base technology of LLMs is too flawed.

Be Careful

---

[Updated 2025-12-11]
Somehow this seems like some kind of poetic justice: compute-intensive grift #1 falls victim to compute-intensive grift #2.

Smart Contracts: Dumb Idea

---

[Updated 2025-12-13]
I keep hoping this will start slowing down. I believe I am delusional.

Quintafecta

---

[Updated 2025-12-14]
The limit of how far you can go based on statistical correlation between words in corpuses it becoming increasingly and painfully obvious.

There's More To Life Than Statistics

---

[Updated 2025-12-18]
LOL! LLM vending machine converts to communism!

Maybe Need a Rethink?

---

[Updated 2025-12-19]
Please, please, please, don't put LLMs in the hands of small children.

"Children's Safety Is Our Top Priority" - yeah, right.

---

[Updated 2025-12-20]
Creatives are screwed, + more on the commie LLM.

Human Culture Takes a Big Hit

---

[Updated 2025-12-22]
A Golden Age for grifters. Plus, really strange, I observe the NYT changing the title of an article to make it more clickbait.

Actually Pretty Tame

---

[Updated 2025-12-23]
At 14k words, pretty damn long, up there with my review/summary of some of the economics books. But, I think an OK summary of a great book.

My review/summary of "Calling Bullshit" by Carl T. Bergstrom & Jevin D. West.

---

[Updated 2025-12-26]
Doomscrolling is great for toddlers!

Never Too Early To Create Addicts.

---

[Updated 2025-12-31]
The AI giveth, the AI taketh away. Couldn't we just skip the whole thing?

Scammers using AI? Surely Not!.

---

[Updated 2026-01-04]
ChatGPT: “The United States has not invaded Venezuela, and Nicolás Maduro has not been captured.”

It's Band-Aids All The Way Down

---

[Updated 2026-01-06]
As the Bullshit Apocalypse continues, we need a continuously updated clock/counter/whatever for AI slop:

• Words generated;
• Images generated;
• Lines of code generated;
• Centuries to clean up.

{Mis/Dis}information; Maintenance Debt

---

[Updated 2026-01-14]
How can I make it up to dogs?

A Bad Report Card; An Apology to Dogs

---

[Updated 2026-01-14]
The web was getting bad enough without generative AI influencers.

1 Very Good Idea; 1 Very Bad Idea

---

[Updated 2026-01-15]
"The Slop War" is right up there with "Slopacalypse Now" for "phrases I wish I'd invented". I need to up my game ...

Generative AI & AI Slop: Threat or Menace?

---

[Updated 2026-01-19]
The theme of licensing hadn't come up lately ...

You Should Need a License - Again

---

[Updated 2026-01-20]
LLM Use is Correlated with Brain Damage.

Think of the Children

---

[Updated 2026-01-21]
I think I found a study which corroborates the claim in yesterday's post of cognitive decline in adults.

OK, Sure, Brain Damage, But, Primo Slop!

---

[Updated 2026-01-25]
Bullshit away!

The Bullshit is Piling Up

---

[Updated 2026-01-28]
OK, a little humor, but, it's not funny. Being crushed by a juggernaut bullshit technology because it will make some tech bros some money is NOT FUNNY.

Don’t Say Mean Things

---

[Updated 2026-01-31]
Yay, a post about fighting bullshit in general, rather than tilting against the generative AI juggernaut windmill.

An Excellent Bullshit Detection Primer

---

[Updated 2026-02-02]
IMO normally the scary "AIs are coming for us" stories I interpret as marketoids inflating LLM capabilities. I actually found the articles on OpenClaw/MoltBot/Moltbook scary.

Nice That We Have Professionals Weighing In

---

[Updated 2026-02-08]
Almost a week since the last. Bullshit Fatigue.

Bullshit Fatigue => Bullshit Apocalypse

---

[Updated 2026-02-10]
Heading to Guadeloupe for a week tomorrow. Bullshit Apocalypse can pile up in my absence, I'm not draining the RSS feed for a week! J'aime a essayer a parler la belle langue francaise!

.345 Is A Great Batting Average!

---

[Updated 2026-02-23]
Back from Guadeloupe. That may be our last Caribbean vacation. We'll see.

16 articles piled up since we left. This is I think the most important. I have not seen this expressed before.

Semantic Ablation

---

[Updated 2026-02-26]
It's going to be a real slog to get through this backlog. Oh well, 3 down, 19 to go ...

AI Ruins Everything

---

[Updated 2026-02-27]
1 normal LLM screwup, 2 more wide-ranging links.

"Bullshit All The Way Down" Recurses???

---

[Updated 2026-03-01]
3 different outlooks.

If You Hate AI, Does It Hate You Back?

---

[Updated 2026-03-03]
2 great band names!

The Promptware Kill Chain / Counterfeit People

---

[Updated 2026-03-07]
We are surely living in the Golden Age of Grifting.

A Scam? A Scam?

---

[Updated 2026-03-08]
Special commemorative post celebrating my 100th article on the Bullshit Apocalypse!

What Is It Good For?

---

[Updated 2026-03-09]
Common themes: laziness & fear.

Total Nuclear Destruction; Lazy Kids & Priests

---

[Updated 2026-03-10]
The eternal question: who profits?

Who wants AI? The Greedy; the Gullible; the Ignorant; the Incompetent; the Lazy.

---

[Updated 2026-03-11]
Only 6 articles left! Almost caught up!

Slop Makes For a Slippery Slope

---

[Updated 2026-03-12]
4th post in a row opening with a Gary Marcus article.

Don't Trust Generative AI - Particularly Agents

---

[Updated 2026-03-13]
Somebody stop me!!! 5th straight post opening with a Gary Marcus article.

Right On Schedule

---

[Updated 2026-03-14]
Yay! No Gary Marcus article today! Plus, I'm finally caught up!

AI Stands For "Actually Indians"

---

[Updated 2026-03-18]
Rick Beato's intentions were good, but still, I'm disappointed.

Say It Ain't So, Rick!

---

[Updated 2026-03-19]
So is it just really bad luck that we get the biggest $T scam of all time at the same time as the most incompetent & corrupt government of my lifetime? Or is there correlation or causation?

Now That's Some Bullshit!

---

[Updated 2026-03-22]
Another day, another lying, stealing, delusional LLM.

Wendig Triples Down

---

[Updated 2026-03-24]
It seems like The Resistance to LLM hype is growing.

Notably Mixed Results

---

[Updated 2026-03-25]
I could never understand why Disney agreed to let its incredibly valuable characters be used in AI slop generated by amateurs. It only took them 3 months to realize what a horrible idea this was.

Yay! Disney Bails On OpenAI-Generated Slop Video

---

[Updated 2026-03-26]
2 days in a row! 2 yays in a row!

Yay! Wow, 2 Yays in a Row! The Tide Is Turning!

---

[Updated 2026-03-29]
Another great new term in the dream world of LLM hallucinations: "mirage reasoning".

Now That is Some Bullshit!

---

[Updated 2026-04-08]
Wow, 10 days since the last post! A welcome respite.

Mythos: Threat, Menace, or Just More Bullshit Hype?

---

[Updated 2026-04-12]
Bullshit, bullshit, bullshit!

We Have A Winner: "Just More Bullshit Hype"

---

[Updated 2026-04-14]
Never failing to disappoint.

Human Beings Are Weak

---

[Updated 2026-04-17]
What will it take to get corporations to admit their AI efforts are a waste of time?

Are We Done?

---

[Updated 2026-04-26]
We are living in The Golden Age of Grifting.

Incompetence & Thievery

---

[Updated 2026-05-01]
The bullshit is wearing me out.

Reusing a Title? Bullshit Fatigue.

---

[Updated 2026-05-09]
Gary Marcus is apparently the only one out there who is mensch enough to not succumb to Bullshit Fatigue.

All Gary, All The Time!

---

[Updated 2026-05-17]
All gerunds, all the time! ???

Threatening, Flooding, Tricking, Drowning, Dying

---

[Updated 2026-05-21]
Bullshit Fatigue, the 2nd order crisis.

Flooding the Zone, Part 2

---

[Updated 2026-05-25]
The Bullshit Apocalypse: "A slow-motion car crash".

Claude Sent Me

---

[Updated 2026-05-27]
7 new links in 2 days.

"Solipsism All The Way Down" Doesn't Work

---

[Updated 2026-06-01]
15.5k words. 12.7% of the size of the 122k word original.

My review/summary of "Bullshit Jobs: a Theory".

---

[Updated 2026-06-05]
Recurring themes: Gary Marcus, 404Media, addiction, Semantic Ablation.

The Slow Motion Car Crash Continues

---

[Updated 2026-06-011]
In which I invent the term, "slopiverse"! FTW!

Speciation in the Slopiverse

---

[Updated 2026-06-17]
Proof that "Calling Bullshit" is an eye-opener.

I Fixed It!

---

[Updated 2026-06-26]

My Post to the Lexington Data Center Online Forum

---

[Updated 2026-06-28]
Is "cognitive surrender" the same as "cognitive damage"? Please don't ask a fucking AI ...

The Tokenpocalypse Is Here

---

[Updated 2026-06-30]
I revisit the title of my very 1st Bullshit Apocalypse post.

Eating Bullshit All The Way Down

---

[Updated 2026-07-05]
'Pocalypses everywhere! I should create a new genre of music: apocalypso!

'Pocalypses Are Multiplying

---

[Updated 2026-07-12]
Jobspocalypse or jobless apocalypse?

If It Chats Like A Bot ...

---

[Updated 2026-07-16]
Bubble, bubble, toil & trouble ...

I Can't Believe I Read The Whole Thing!

---

[Updated 2026-07-23]
In which I use a clickbait title :-(

A Generation of Idiots

Mr. Penumbra's 24-Hour Bookstore

"Mr. Penumbra's 24-Hour Bookstore", by Robin Sloan, 2012, 304 pages, 95k words.

I want to call this book "slipstream"? It is not science fiction, nor fantasy? But it does feature a fantastical, mystical society? I'm creating a new category, "library fiction".

It is a charming book. It is a mystery novel, but that term seems reserved for murder mystery, which this is not.

It revolves about books, bookstores, & libraries, how could I not love it? Plus an interesting ending.

Bonus, there was an addendum written the following year, which was included in my eBook: "Ajax Penumbra 1969", 2013, 96 pages, 16k words.

This is the secret origin story of Mr. Penumbra, and, again, is about books & bookstores with some interesting San Francisco history thrown in. Nice!

Music In, 2025, Q1

Following the last Music In post, I'm starting this post January 22, and will maintain it as the quarter progresses.

This was going on pretty smoothly, then for reasons unknown to me, on Friday, March 28, 5 albums I had pre-ordered were released on BandCamp. So some heavy eating at the end of the quarter. I had hoped to release this late April, but, given these late additions, that will probably be pushed back at least a month.

Plus, the 90 track, 5h36m LA fire fundraising album has finally been digested! Such a big beast to have to eat!

1. Franz Ferdinand, "The Human Fear", 2025, 11 tracks, BandCamp. Wow, been awhile since we heard from these guys! "take me home" came out in January, 2004! They seem to have traversed the 2 decades with their sound & energy pretty intact. I have their 2004, 2005, 2013, & 2018 albums, I appear to have missed "Tonight: Franz Ferdinand" in 2009.

   LOL, energetic music like this lately seems to walk a tightrope with me - energetic good, but, not too energetic, too brash.

   But, these tunes are CATCHY! After only a few listens, they are popping up on My Hit Parade, the music that is always playing in my head. Impressive!

   Most of their other albums are 3 stars, this is definitely 4 stars. Still, shows how much I have inflated from 3 to 4 stars over the last decade or 2. Here's "Audacious".

2. Nenei, "New Sensations, 2022, 11 tracks. This came from my list, I think suggested by my oldest daughter. Nenei is Brazilian, and is giving a bossa nova twist to some pop tunes. Some guest artists. Not that good a voice IMO. She does "what a difference a day makes" which I do. 3 stars.

3. Fu-Schnickens, "F.U. "Don't Take It Personal"", 1992, 10 tracks. Recommended by Cory Doctorow in his Pluralistic blog. This seems like peak rap. The diction skills of their main rapper are incredible, really fast & clean. I tire of listening to it quickly if I play it as an album. But individual tunes in shuffle play are not bad. 3 stars.

4. The Weather Station, "Humanhood", 2025, 13 tracks, BandCamp. This is the 7th album by the Toronto band which is the brainchild of vocalist/guitarist Tamara Lindeman. I was going to go 3 stars, but the title track has a flute in it, so, 4 stars!!!

5. Bonnie "Prince" Billy, "The Purple Bird", 2025, 12 tracks, BandCamp. The latest from a favorite son of Louisville. He had a couple of albums that were kind of downers. In this one, he hits his stride again. Great tunes, on a variety of topics. 4 stars. Here's a nice oom-pah song, "guns are for cowards".

6. Victoria Port, "Did It Again", 2025, 4 tracks, BandCamp. London-based neo-motown. Very easy to listen to. Here's "Cigarette".

7. Various Artists, "Good Music to Lift Los Angeles", 2025, 90 tracks, BandCamp. A benefit album, I think they wanted $30, I gave them $60 - I broke my $1/track rule.

   Wow, this thing is just so huge! 90 tracks! What, 10-15 albums? 5 hrs & 36 minutes! & consistently high quality. I was going to recommend it to my daughter & others, but, it was a 1 day only deal?!?!? I'm glad I got it, but, why don't they want me to share it, & other people to buy it ?!?!?

   Here are the artists I recognized:

   1. R.E.M. Doing "Electrolyte", 1 of their big hits?
   2. Death Cab for Cutie and The Postal Service
   3. Neko Case
   4. TV On The Radio
   5. Jeff Tweedy
   6. The War on Drugs
   7. Tenacious D. Jack Black's band, yes? Their cover of "Keep On Lovin' You" was the 1st 1 I dropped from my "current listening" playlist.
   8. Modest Mouse
   9. Little Dragon
   10. My Morning Jacket. Their cover of "Together Again", a country standard, was meh.
   11. Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit
   12. Soccer Mommy
   13. Animal Collective
   14. Lucius
   15. Interpol
   16. Dirty Projectors
   17. The New Pornographers
   18. Soul Asylum
   19. Cunningham Bird

   So, 19 out of 90! Still have this in the "burning in" rotation. It's just so much! The quality is overall so good.

   Here are the covers I recognized:

   1. "Fade Into You", Perfume Genius.
   2. "Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite", K. Flay.
   3. "Keep On Lovin' You", Tenacious D.
   4. "Together Again", My Morning Jacket.
   5. "The One I Love", Jason Isbell & the 400 Unit.
   6. "Woodstock", Chelsea Wolfe.
   7. "Porcelain", Porches. I've always loved this Chili Pepper's song, it's in my book.
   8. "My Best Friend's Girl", Centro-matic feat. Jason Isbell and Sadler Vaden.
   9. "Enjoy the Silence", Death Cab for Cutie and The Postal Service.

   Here are the bands whose content stuck out enough for me to buy an album:

   1. Hippo Campus, "Flood". Emo indy rock.
   2. The Dip, "Love Direction". Very funky, dance music.
   3. Shannon Lay, "All this life goin down", 2017, 10 tracks. Out of CA. Ethereal chick pop, I bought her 1st of 4-5 albums, which was not recorded in her basement.
   4. Faye Webster, "Faye Webster", also 2017, 10 tracks. Out of Atlanta. I bought her 1st album out of 4-5.
   5. Local Natives, "Violet Street", 2019, 10 tracks. Out of LA, this was their 4th album. I was going to start with their 1st (2010), but it didn't seem to be on BandCamp.

8. Shotgun Jazz Band, "Algiers Strut", 2011, 13 tracks, BandCamp. I think I liked a track of their stuff & wound up going to BandCamp & buying their whole catalog - 6 albums, 1 single, 2011-present - for $66.78. Not sure what I was thinking. I decided to download the albums in chronological order, maybe 1/month or so. This 1 is the oldest.

   Ugh, the engineering on the 1st album is horrible. The vocalist sounds like she is in another room. At times the horns drown her out completely. I listened to it a few times to see if my ear would acclimate, but it remains totally annoying, straining to make out the vocals. I asked Bandcamp for a full refund, for all the albums. They did so immediately, yay! Nice work, BandCamp!

9. Hippo Campus, "Flood", 2024, 13 tracks, BandCamp. I've listened to the "Good Music to Lift LA" maybe 5 x now. 90 tracks is a lot! This is the 1st band whose tune made me want to buy an album. Nice indie rock, reminiscent of Grizzly Bear or Ra Ra Riot. 4 stars. Here's "Corduroy".

10. katie dey, "anomalies", 2025, 11 tracks, BandCamp. 2 stars for "O Holy Night". katie has been really prolific & generally enjoyable, this is starting to sound too much like modern pop to me. 4 chords, I-IV-vi-V. 3 stars.

11. Jason Isbell, "Foxes in the Snow", 2025, 11 tracks, BandCamp. Isbell's breakup album, from his wife, fiddler & vocalist & 400 unit member Amanda Shires. They had a daughter together. Appropriate that he does this a a solo album, just him & an acoustic guitar.

    I think this song, "True Believer", is the essence of this breakup album. The chorus starts:

    All your girlfriends say I broke your fucking heart, and I don't like it.

    A nice collection of great tunes, 4 stars.

12. Snowgoose, "Descendant", 2024, 11 tracks, BandCamp. From Glasgow. Very poppy. I think I saw something about Belle & Sebastian tie-ins? 4 stars. Here's the 1st track, "Better Listen".

13. Taidi Tatham, "Miles Away", 2025, 20 tracks, BandCamp. Like all of Taidi's stuff, this is very listenable. Almost makes me want to quit bad-mouthing jazz. But, after several listens to this album, nothing is really standing out. So, 3 stars.

14. Omar, "Research & Brighter The Days", 2025, 5 tracks, BandCamp. I love Omar. He reminds me of Stevie Wonder and Al Green. Great beats. 4 stars. Here's "Brighter The Days".

15. Unknown Mortal Orchestra, "IC-02 Bogotá", 2025, 8 tracks, BandCamp. This is very unlike their earlier albums. No vocals. Kind of reminded me of the David Byrne/Brian Eno album that was all sound effects. 3 stars

16. Destroyer, "Dan's Boogie", 2025, 9 tracks, BandCamp. Well, after several albums, I think I finally am tired of Dan's voice. Plus, the songs sound really similar to his earlier stuff. 3 stars.

17. Criibaby, "in the garden", 2025, 7 tracks, BandCamp. Oh, clever, I just noticed all the songs have "(in the garden)" appended to their titles. Most of the tracks have guest artists. This is the last one for Q1, I had been noticing that it was a lot of instrumentals. I just finished listening to it again - only the last track has vocals. These are nice tunes, very chill, very ethereal. But I would have liked more vocals. 3 stars.

Phew, what a slog! Here is it mid-June. Well, I can finally move on to the Q2 music. So far only 11 albums, hopefully they're won't be a deluge at the end like last quarter. It would be nice to not be processing new music all the time, to go back & listen, but, in terms of getting to be an older and older man, I don't think I should stop.

The Devils

"The Devils", by Joe Abercrombie, 2025, 576 pages, 224k words.

I enjoyed his Shattered Seas trilogy, wow, all the way back in 2018, blogged here. He's a Brit & a gritty writer.

I thought this was mentioned as the 1st of a trilogy, but I can't find anything to confirm that. So maybe it's standalone.

This is basically a Suicide Squad kind of setup: convicted miscreants are the pope's Mission Impossible team. They are led by a cleric, and include a werewolf, a vampire, an immortal warrior, a magician, a fixer, and an elf. Sounds like D&D. Their mission is to place the young thief who is the long lost Empress of Troy back on the throne.

It's a very nice alternate history. Jebus was a woman & was broken on the wheel rather than crucified, so their holy symbol is the circle rather than the cross. The pope & most of the church officials are women. Troy won the Trojan War & still is the major power of eastern Europe. Carthage defeated Rome? And the crusades were fought against invading elves rather than Moslems.

It's definitely a page turner, a lot of fun.

Bullshit Machines

Thanks to Doc Searls for this post, which includes links to 2 articles on AI-based bullshit!

1. In the Financial Times, "Generative AI models are skilled in the art of bullshit". This may be paywalled.

   It opens with Harry Frankfurt and "On Bullshit", for which I just published a review/summary.

   Here's a nice picture of Harry:

   
2. "Modern Day Oracles or Bullshit Machines".

   Yet for all the good that AI systems will do, they will also saturate our information environment with bullshit at a scale we’ve never before encountered.

   An online course, 18 5-10 minute lessons. Looks very impressive & comprehensive. Puts my efforts to shame :-( But, it figures, as the 2 authors are college professors, rather than a retired dumbass.

---

Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit.

Scientist AI, FTW?

This blog post by Robin Sloan:

Only oracular

links to and comments on this very interesting research paper from Cornell:

Superintelligent Agents Pose Catastrophic Risks: Can Scientist AI Offer a Safer Path?

I haven't read the Cornell paper yet, up soonest. I wanted to capture this, regardless. That's what a blog used to be, yes? A weblog where you record interesting things you found on the web.

---

Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit

4 Quickies

As the writing of my review/summary of "On Bullshit" drug out to over a month, I imposed a "no new novels until you're finished" edict. But, there were a few x where i wasn't going to work on the review/summary & didn't want to do music or doomscroll, when I went on and read a short story. All of these were by 3 of my favorite authors, I think purchased for $0.99 or $1.99. They had maybe been online originals at Tor.com? So these aren't a real reading $$$ value, but I am happy to support these authors.

1. "Human Resources", by Adrian Tchaikovsky, 2025, 32 pages, 4k words. A somewhat Kafkaesque tale of the coming AI revolution in an "Office Space" environment. It ends with some very heavy-handed humor.

2. "The Tale of the Wicked", by John Scalzi, 2023, 25 pages, 7k words. I think I had read this before. Again, AI leads to unexpected results in interstellar fleets.

3. "Vigilant", by Cory Doctorow, 2024, 29 pages, 9k words. Doctorow has created his own genre: exposes and takedowns of crap software systems. One of his novels recently did prison systems software which rips off prisoners for visits, books, you name it. This short story is about remote student surveillance software. Kobo says it is in the "Little Brother" series.

4. "The Canadian Miracle", by Cory Doctorow, 2023, 23 pages, 5k words. Set in the world of "The Lost Cause", where some more progressive countries have made progress against the climate crisis, while others more under the thumb of Big Oil are facing more of a struggle. Canadian "blue helmets" trying to help out in Mississippi run afoul of MAGAts.

On Bullshit

"On Bullshit", by Harry Frankfurt (1929-2023), was originally published as an essay in 1986 in the Raritan Quarterly Review, then republished as a book in 2005.

It is only 20 pages, < 8k words - $9.99 on Kobo, expensive! Here's a link to a PDF at some university. If it goes away, I'm sure DuckDuckGo can find you another one.

I had assumed that the book would be an expansion on the essay, but I read a review that said, no, the book was the essay, word for word.

This book is very short. I recently read it again. I have thought up 2 possible 1 line reviews:

1. "'On Bullshit', by philosophy professor Harry Frankfurt, is bullshit."

2. "In 'On Bullshit', philosophy professor Harry Frankfort bullshits about bullshit and bullshitting."

And, I'm really not just being snarky here. He starts out so noncommital, so wishy-washy, I couldn't help but wonder, is he writing this tongue-in-cheek? Or, bullshitting about bullshitting, is he as big a fan of self-reference as I am?

Let's take his 1st utterance re bullshit:

we have no clear understanding of what bullshit is, why there is so much of it, or what functions it serves.

I would say that everyone could immediately start answering those 3 questions, including Frankfurt, and that is what he says he's going to do.

This next particularly threw me:

I have not undertaken a survey of the literature, partly because I do not know how to go about it.

??? I mean, when the essay came out, Frankfurt was a 57 YO college professor. I thought when a college professor came up with an idea for a new avenue of exploration, they called in 1-2 of their grad students and said "Hey, check out {$blah}, see what you can find out." No?

But he immediately contradicts himself and moves to another short essay, "The Prevalance of Humbug", by Max Black (1909-1988), 1980, and starts heavily excerpting it. Here's a link to that essay. It is longer than this one, but still only 10k words. I guess I will write a review of it next? Black was also a philosopher.

Frankfurt explains that humbug is the polite and less intense version of bullshit.

Black suggests a number of synonyms for humbug, including the following: balderdash, claptrap, hokum, drivel, buncombe, imposture, and quackery. This list of quaint equivalents is not very helpful. But Black also confronts the problem of establishing the nature of humbug more directly, and he offers the following formal definition:

HUMBUG: deceptive misrepresentation, short of lying, especially by pretentious word or deed, of somebody’s own thoughts, feelings, or attitudes.

Hmmm, in the list of synonyms, I looked up "buncombe" - it is probably more commonly "bunk", and probably also the root of "bunco" as in "bunco squad".

Frankfurt now takes Black's definition & goes over it point by point. [This reminded me of the discussion of the elements of a Basic Good in "How Much Is Enough? Money and the Good Life", the 1st serious book I reviewed/summarized in 2012. 1 of the authors of that book was a philosopher, so I guess this is a philosopher thing ...]

• Deceptive misrepresentation. Frankfurt describes this further as "deliberate" misrepresentation. Then there's some philosophical discussion of how heavily the intent, the state of mind of the speaker, figures in the humbug.

  I really feel this totally misses the essence of bullshit - that it is post-truth.

• short of lying. "What continuum could this be, along which one encounters humbug only before one encounters lying? Both lying and humbug are modes of misrepresentation." This might be a useful concept.

• especially by pretentious word or deed. Frankfurt mentions how "'pretentious bullshit' is close to being a stock phrase." But he then makes what I think is a good point:

  I am inclined to think that when bullshit is pretentious, this happens because pretentiousness is its motive rather than a constitutive element of its essence.

• misrepresentation ... of somebody’s own thoughts, feelings, or attitudes.

  whenever a person deliberately misrepresents anything, he must inevitably be misrepresenting his own state of mind.

  Somehow to me the person's state of mind has nothing to do with it. Maybe because I'm not a philosophy professor?

Frankfurt presents as an example of something that is clearly humbug, a Fourth of July orator, spewing patriotic blather.

It is clear that what makes Fourth of July oration humbug is not fundamentally that the speaker regards his statements as false. Rather, just as Black’s account suggests, the orator intends these statements to convey a certain impression of himself. He is not trying to deceive anyone concerning American history. What he cares about is what people think of him.

I find Black's concept of humbug pretty uncompelling. Oh wait, Frankfurt does too!

I do not believe that it adequately or accurately grasps the essential character of bullshit. It is correct to say of bullshit, as he says of humbug, both that it is short of lying and that those who perpetrate it misrepresent themselves in a certain way. But Black’s account of these two features is significantly off the mark.

So next up, a real heavy hitter: Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951).

Wittgenstein once said that the following bit of verse by Longfellow could serve him as a motto:

In the elder days of art
Builders wrought with greatest care
Each minute and unseen part,
For the Gods are everywhere.

The point of these lines is clear. In the old days, craftsmen did not cut corners. They worked carefully, and they took care with every aspect of their work. Every part of the product was considered, and each was designed and made to be exactly as it should be. These craftsmen did not relax their thoughtful self-discipline even with respect to features of their work that would ordinarily not be visible. Although no one would notice if those features were not quite right, the craftsmen would be bothered by their consciences. So nothing was swept under the rug. Or, one might perhaps also say, there was no bullshit.

It does seem fitting to construe carelessly made, shoddy goods as in some way analogues of bullshit.

...

Is the bullshitter by his very nature a mindless slob? Is his product necessarily messy or unrefined? The word shit does, to be sure, suggest this. Excrement is not designed or crafted at all; it is merely emitted, or dumped. It may have a more or less coherent shape, or it may not, but it is in any case certainly not wrought.

The notion of carefully wrought bullshit involves, then, a certain inner strain.

Again, I find sloppiness as a hallmark of bullshit completely unconvincing. After all, advertising and propaganda are both carefully crafted. Oh wait, Frankfort agrees with me!

The realms of advertising and of public relations, and the nowadays closely related realm of politics, are replete with instances of bullshit so unmitigated that they can serve among the most indusputable and classic paradigms of the concept.

[Hmmm, I am reminded that I read & summarized the 1928 book "Propaganda", by Edward Bernays, the father of PR, in 2018. I need to read my summary.]

Frankfort tells a story about Wittgenstein going off on a friend, Fania Pascal, recovering from a surgery:

I [the friend] croaked: "I feel just like a dog that has been run over." He was disgusted: "You don't know what a dog that has been run over feels like."

Maybe Ludwig was joking with her? The friend was clearly using a "figure of speech", yes? She wasn't lying.

Hers is not just any bad feeling but, according to her account, the distinctive kind of bad feeling that a dog has when it is run over. To the Wittgenstein in Pascal’s story, judging from his response, this is just bullshit.

...

Her fault is not that she fails to get things right, but that she is not even trying.

From this, a strong statement from Frankfort:

Her statement is grounded neither in a belief that it is true nor, as a lie must be, in a belief that it is not true. It is just this lack of connection to a concern with truth — this indifference to how things really are — that I regard as the essence of bullshit.

Hmmm. Maybe.

Frankfort explores the dictionary for more info about bull.

1st, a discussion of bull sessions:

it is understood by everyone in a bull session that the statements people make do not necessarily reveal what they really believe or how they really feel.

...

the usual assumptions about the connection between what people say and what they believe are suspended. The statements made in a bull session differ from bullshit in that there is no pretense that this connection is being sustained.

2nd:

a British usage of bull in which, according to the OED, the term refers to “unnecessary routine tasks or ceremonial; excessive discipline or ‘spit-and-polish’; = red-tape.”

So maybe, anticipating the now common term "bullshit job".

3rd:

The term bull is also employed, in a rather more widespread and familiar usage, as a somewhat less coarse equivalent of bullshit. In an entry for bull as so used, the OED suggests the following as definitive: “trivial, insincere, or untruthful talk or writing; nonsense.”

Frankfort disagrees with "trivial" and "nonsense", I concur.

LOL, again hard to know if Frankfort is bullshitting or not. He discusses "hot air":

No more information is communicated than if the speaker had merely exhaled. There are similarities between hot air and excrement, incidentally, which make hot air seem an especially suitable equivalent for bullshit.

Frankfort moves on to bullshit as a verb:

Now consider these lines from Pound’s Canto LXXIV, which the OED cites in its entry on bullshit as a verb:

Hey Snag wots in the bibl’?
Wot are the books ov the bible?
Name ’em, don’t bullshit ME.

This is a call for the facts.

...

he is calling the bluff. The connection between bullshit and bluff is affirmed explicitly in the definition with which the lines by Pound are associated:

As v. trans. and intr., to talk nonsense (to); … also, to bluff one’s way through (something) by talking nonsense.

It does seem that bullshitting involves a kind of bluff. It is closer to bluffing, surely, than to telling a lie.

We're back to our continuum of modes of misrepresentation:

Lying and bluffing are both modes of misrepresentation or deception.

Another statement re the "essence of bullshit":

For the essence of bullshit is not that it is false but that it is phony. ... What is wrong with a counterfeit is not what it is like, but how it was made. This points to a similar and fundamental aspect of the essential nature of bullshit: although it is produced without concern with the truth, it need not be false.

Frankfort recounts advice a father gives a child in Eric Ambler's 1967 novel Dirty Story:

One of the first things he taught me was, “Never tell a lie when you can bullshit your way through.”

Why? Is the following true?

people do tend to be more tolerant of bullshit than of lies, perhaps because we are less inclined to take the former as a personal affront.

Does this support that assertion?

The [father] identifies the alternative to telling a lie as “bullshitting one’s way through.” This involves not merely producing one instance of bullshit; it involves a program of producing bullshit to whatever extent the circumstances require. This is a key, perhaps, to his preference. Telling a lie is an act with a sharp focus.

This leads Frankfort to the well known concept of a bullshit artist.

a person who undertakes to bullshit his way through has much more freedom. His focus is panoramic rather than particular. ... It is more expansive and independent, with more spacious opportunities for improvisation, color, and imaginative play. This is less a matter of craft than of art. Hence the familiar notion of the "bullshit artist".

Is the Orange Turd a bullshit artist, or what? The above describes him very well. His 1 skill besides bullying. Hard to believe that is all it takes to destroy the US hegemony of the last 70 years.

Frankfort now references another heavy hitter:

In his essay “Lying,” Saint Augustine distinguishes lies of eight types, which he classifies according to the characteristic intent or justification with which a lie is told. ... It is only the remaining category that contains what he identifies as “the lie which is told solely for the pleasure of lying and deceiving, that is, the real lie.”

The essay by St. Augustine (354-430) is our longest so far, 19k words. Here's a link to it. It may actually be titled "On Lying". It was written around 395 a.d. I guess it goes in the reading list too.

I don't think Frankfort has much use for St. Augustine's definition of "real lying".

Moving on, he starts to wrap it up:

He [a bullshitter] does not reject the authority of the truth, as the liar does, and oppose himself to it. He pays no attention to it at all. By virtue of this, bullshit is a greater enemy of the truth than lies are.

...

Why is there so much bullshit? Of course it is impossible to be sure that there is relatively more of it nowadays than at other times. There is more communication of all kinds in our time than ever before, but the proportion that is bullshit may not have increased. Without assuming that the incidence of bullshit is actually greater now, I will mention a few considerations that help to account for the fact that it is currently so great.

Bullshit is unavoidable whenever circumstances require someone to talk without knowing what he is talking about. ... Closely related instances arise from the widespread conviction that it is the responsibility of a citizen in a democracy to have opinions about everything, or at least everything that pertains to the conduct of his country’s affairs.

...

The contemporary proliferation of bullshit also has deeper sources, in various forms of skepticism which deny that we can have any reliable access to an objective reality, and which therefore reject the possibility of knowing how things truly are.

That last clearly calls to mind Qanon and "deep state" conspiracy theories.

One response to this loss of confidence has been a retreat from the discipline required by dedication to the ideal of correctness to a quite different sort of discipline, which is imposed by pursuit of an alternative ideal of sincerity. Rather than seeking primarily to arrive at accurate representations of a common world, the individual turns toward trying to provide honest representations of himself.

I'd have to say Frankfort is less that impressed with this approach. LOL, the last 4 words of the book:

sincerity itself is bullshit.

I just don't know! It's all gotten too meta for me! Is he bullshitting us or not, I don't know. I also think that all the discussions here come from earlier, simpler times. The world of post-truth has been developing since, what, WWII? But it has clearly accelerated, nay, warp-shifted with the onset of the Orange Turd bullshitter-in-chief. I think we need a different approach than the philosophical analysis vaguely attempted here.

---

Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit.

Detect hallucinations for RAG-based systems

The article "Detect hallucinations for RAG-based systems" was just published in the AWS (Amazon Web Services) blog. I'm sure this article will be as ROFL as their last one on hallucinations - or as I like to call them, ERRONEOUS RESPONSES, or WRONG ANSWERS, or INCORRECT ANSWERS, or FALSE ANSWERS.

I will leave it to the reader to spot all the bullshit in this article.

I do note, they claim: "Hallucinations can be categorized into three types,"

1. Input-conflicting;
2. Context-conflicting;
3. Fact-conflicting.

So many different kinds of wrong. This might need to be incorporated into my WIP "A Taxonomy of Bullshit".

---

Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit.

The Best Science Fiction of the Year Volume 7

"The Best Science Fiction of the Year Volume 7" edited by Neil Clarke, 2023, 800 pages, 248k words, 31 stories: 22 short stories (< 7500 words), 7 novelettes (< 17500 words), 2 novellas (< 40000 words).

This volume covers 2021, but was not released until December 29, 2023??? I guess Clarke was busy?

---

"Proof by Induction", by José Pablo Iriarte I enjoyed because it was about 2 mathematicians, 1 of them dead, working on 1 of those impossible proofs.

---

This was followed by "Integral Nothings", by Robert Reed - 2 math references in a row. This is a fun story to read, with sections focusing on people who are "the world's {$blah}est {$something}". Very powerful technology is fixing the world, surely that's a good thing?

---

"Paley's Watch" by Anil Manon was a fun story, about the discovery of a random alien artifact.

---

"Vaccine Season" by Hannu Rajaniemi I had already read in the 2021 edition of MIT Technology Review's "Twelve Tomorrows" annual collection, titled "Make Shift", blogged here. Here's what I said about the story then, after complaining about a raft of pandemic stories in the collection:

The last story, "Vaccine Season" by Hannu Rajaniemi, gave an incredibly hopefully future vision. Phew, thanks Hannu, I needed that!

It is a great story, I enjoyed the reread.

---

"Where There are Cities, These Dissolve Too" by S. Qiouyi Lu is a very visceral story about garbage mining machines repurposed to be human piloted battle bots in the arena. It is also a story of love and betrayal. Kudos to ær for creating ær own pronoun?

---

"Hānai" by Gregory Norman Bossert is a cute story about the last member of a manatee-like race dancing the hula.

---

"The Equations of the Dead" by An Owomoyela has a nice, authentic noir feel to it.

---

"The Trolley Solution" by Shiv Ramdas is a very nice, very thoughtful exploration of the role of "AI" in education.

---

"Aptitude" by Cooper Shrivastava is interesting & somewhat playful, describing candidates for admission to a universe-building school undergoing their entrance exam.

---

"The Tide of Moon City" by Regina Kanyu Wang, translated by Xueting Christine Ni, I found sophomoric & completely trite. One wonders if it was the original story or the translation.

---

"A Rocket for Dimitrios" by Ray Nayler was incredibly fun, an alternative history where the US wins WWII & becomes the world's overlord via alien tech found from the flying saucer crash at Roswell. Can you say, disintegrator rays? Nayler's latest (2nd?) novel is just out, I am really looking forward to it.

---

"Jaunt" by Ken Liu was a great read. A post-covid story in which telepresence goes wild. MAGAts, of course, don't like it.

---

"The Water Beneath Our Feet" by Alice Towey was a nice story about a farming cyborg with a big heart.

---

"Elegba's Valley" by Tade Thompson was an interesting story exploring an attempt to implement Abundance in an African country.

---

"He Leaps For The Stars, He Leaps For The Stars" by Grace Chan brought to the surface of my thinking something that been trying to break through. The story is about a young man trying to win the solar system talent contest or some such. The candidate performers are bred specifically for this. From the time they can walk, they are taught to be singers, dancers, celebrities. I think the reason I find it hard to engage with most of the modern pop stars is that this is not actually too far from their life stories. They are on Disney shows from the time they are young children, by their late teens-early 20s they are ready for pop stardom. Completely manufactured.

---

"Complete Exhaustion of the Organism" by Rich Larson is gritty and penetrating as always. But, I'm not sure what the message of this story was, if it had one.

---

"Bots of the Lost Ark" by Suzanne Palmer is a cute bot story. It was surprising when a human being finally showed up in the story, which had heretofore had lots of interesting and creative bots' goings-ons.

---

So, 17 out of 31 stories mentioned above, 16 positive, 1 negative. Just over half. I guess I'll start posting that number. I am indeed a geek.

The Half Life of Empire

This is a must-read article, it makes so much sense:

The Half Life of Empire
Economics from the Top Down
Blair Fix

I have been advocating for a while a peaceful & orderly handoff of the hegemony from the US to China, so we can maybe avoid winding up in the dustbin of history like the UK.

Oops, too late.

The half life - the time during which it comsumed over half of the % of the world’s energy as it did at its peak - of the British Empire was 1850-1952, peaking in 1900.

The half life of the US hegemony was 1889 to 2008, peaking in 1945.

In 2009, China’s energy consumption passed the US. “Within a few years, China will consume double the energy of the United States.“

The American century is over. The Chinese century has begun.

I, for one, welcome our new Chinese hegemons.

The Orange Turd as an Hallucinating LLM

Kottke links to a very interesting article "The Hallucinating ChatGPT Presidency". I shared (in NewsBlur) Kottke's post, with the comment, "The Orange Turd is indeed the prophet of the coming Bullshit Apocalypse." Here's 2 excerpts from the article:

The key thing is this: These models are designed to give you what you want, not what’s true. They optimize for plausibility rather than accuracy, delivering confident-sounding answers because that’s what humans tend to find satisfying. It’s a bit like having a very articulate friend who’s willing to hold forth on any topic, regardless of whether they actually know anything about it.

...

The key insight isn’t just that Trump makes things up (though he does). It’s that his response generation follows the same fundamental patterns as an LLM: Take an input, process it through a set of fixed parameters (“always claim victory,” “never admit error,” “blame others”), and generate a confident-sounding response with little regard for factual accuracy.

It's a really good, quick read. They take a recent Orange Turd interview & run it through an LLM. The LLM is as full of bullshit as the Orange Turd is, but is actually quite a bit more coherent - duh. The Bullshit Apocalypse approaches ...

---

Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit.

Ymir

"Ymir", by Rich Larson, 2022, 297 pages, 92k words.

This book seemed longer than 92k words? I must be slowing down.

Larson really has stood out in the Clarke's Years Best Sci Fi collections, of which I have read the 1st 6, bringing me up to 2020. This is Larson's 2nd & most recent novel. I guess if I want to read more of his stuff I will have to go back to the Year's Best collections.

Ymir is the frost giant of norse creation myths. In this book, it is an icy planet with lots of yummy minerals. The mining corporation is as nasty as you would imagine. The corporate enslavement technology is chilling. [Sorry for the bad pun.]

I guess that this is a riff on Beowulf. In this universe, there is advanced technology left behind by a disappeared alien race. Some of that are cyborgs - organic & machine components - very hard to kill. Of course they are called grendels. When a mining operation is attacked, the corporation calls in a grendel-killer. Our horribly flawed protagonist is a native of Ymir, and had noped to never return. He is really, really not popular.

Larson's writing often reminds me of Gibson's Neuromancer & its horribly flawed protagonist Case. This is high praise from me, the run at the end of Neuromancer is 1 of the most memorable action sequences in modern sci fi.

Anyway, I enjoyed the book. I still wonder why it felt more like 400 pages to me? The pacing was brisk. Hmmm, not a problem worth spending any time on. Moving right along ...

When The Moon Hits Your Eye

"When The Moon Hits Your Eye", by John Scalzi, 2025, 328 pages, 101k words.

So, suddenly, the moon turns to cheese - we are never told what kind. It maintains the same mass, so it gets a little bigger, and it is brighter too.

Scalzi is the king of snark. This book is like a gedanken experiment to see how many snarky riffs Scalzi can come up with. There are a few recurring sets of characters, and also characters who only get 1 chapter. As I expected, LOL funny in lots of places.

I wonder what genre this is though? Maybe magical realism, rather than science fiction? It is a quick & fun read.

The Machineries of Empire

The Machineries of Empire is a trilogy by Yoon Ha Lee, a Korean American mathematician & author & a trans man. It is quite a fusion - a space opera, but with technology that is more fantasy and horror than science fictional. The 3 books are:

#1, "Ninefox Gambit", 2016, 364 pages, 99k words.

#2, "Raven Strategem", 2017, 408 pages, 111k words.

#3, "Revenant Gun", 2018, 465 pages, 126k words.

I really liked 1 of the author's short stories in the Clarke Year's Best collection, so I decided to try the trilogy.

I liked the 1st novel for the main character being a mathematician, and their tech being math-based - it made me think of "Neverness" by David Zindell, which we loved Back In The Day.

This civilization is really odd. Originally 7 clans, now 6, their "exotic" tech is powered by adherence to a liturgical calendar. Feast days feature ritual torture of heretics - people who don't want to follow the calendar - which is required to keep the calendar working?!?!?

The 1st book has 2 big events happen.

The 2nd book has 1 big event, & 1 of the major characters decides to absent themselves from the book. That seemed, I don't know, soap opera'ish to me?

The 3rd book has 1 big event. It opens with 1 of the major characters with amnesia - again, a popular soap opera trope.

The stories are kind of slow moving in-between the big events. I noticed they got steadily longer - I'm not sure that was a good thing.

In addition to the odd calendar-based tech stuff, I also found it odd that they had robots that had (recently) become sentient whom they just kind of ignored? That sure seemed like an odd blind spot.

I stayed fairly engaged going throuogh the 3, but at the end, I was really unsure if these were worth the time invested.

Wow, almost 6 years ago I posted "I am definitely not going to read any more books with "empire" in the title." These books have really great & catchy titles, but the series is named "The Machineries of Empire". So maybe I should have followed that resolution?

I also have a collection of his short stories set in this universe. I am guessing I will like these more, but I think it may be a while before I get back to them.

A Portrait of the Citizen Scientist as an Old Man

This post was originally titled "A Portrait of the Dilettante as an Old Man".

I am in my 6th decade of being a dilettante in my spare time.

Hmmm, "dilettante" may be too harsh. Here's "dilettante" in the online American Heritage® Dictionary:

dilettante /dĭl′ĭ-tänt″, dĭl″ĭ-tänt′, -tănt′/

noun

1. One who dabbles in an art or a field of knowledge.
2. A lover of the fine arts.
3. An admirer or lover of the fine arts; popularly, an amateur; especially, one who follows an art or a branch of knowledge, desultorily, or for amusement only.

I've spent far too many hours on this "art" or these "fields of knowledge" for me to consider it "dabbling", or my interest "desultory". And "for amusement only" seems somewhat demeaning, or at a minimum inaccurate? And while "amateur" has connotions of non-seriousness, in reality it just means "unpaid".

I was a professional astronomer & software developer, & I am currently a semi-pro musician, so I was being paid for my interest, at least at the start. That is, of course, all that matters - making $$$ [sarcasm]. [Capitalism ruins everything.]

Seriously though, I have been clearly a citizen scientist on at least 2 projects:

1. As an assistant/2nd pair of hands for my wife taking dozens of water samples of local creeks for Kentucky River Watershed Watch.

2. As a birder, entering 100s of bird lists & compiling to date 4 annual reports on "Birdwatching in Islandwalk". These have shown, I believe, how a program to increase littoral plantings, in particular spike rushes, to control bank erosion, has led to a large increase in our population of common gallinules and american coots, both of whom seem to really like the reeds.

So I will consider all these side activities of mine to be those of a citizen scientist. Hence the new and improved post title. ;->

---

My areas of interest over the years, until very recently:

1. Astronomy/astrophysics, particularly cosmology, extragalactic astronomy, clusters & superclusters of galaxies. My private cosmology, in which the big bang was actually ongoing fissions of pieces of the big bang (retarded cores) left behind in the center of active galaxies - the big bang as zygote - doesn't work. I did work as a professional astronomer 1972-1974.

2. Intelligence, natural & artificial, including evolutionary psychology & theories of mind & consciousness. When I read 3 books in a row where all of it - big brains, language, intelligence, consciousness - were attributed to sexual selection - i.e., "chicks dig it" - rather than species selection, i.e., "survival of the fittest", I was done with that. I did create computerized rule-based expert systems 1982-1986.

3. Economics, or more accurately abundance, blogged extensively here as "Economy of Plenty". Since my retirement from computing in September, 2012, I have read & reviewed/summarized 32 books on economic topics. After determining that economics is not a science - I'm not sure what it is - I discovered MMT, which posits, money is all just arithmetic [currently mostly rigged the way the oligarchs want it]; resources - both sources & sinks - are what we should be worried about. Based on part of MMT, I invented a branch of economics, stability economics! So I'm mostly done with that. I never worked in economics, my status is indeed "amateur".

4. I started singing age 7, playing guitar age 14, played in 3 rock bands in the Boston area aged 18-23, Back In The Day: 1970-1974. Since 2006, I have mostly been a semi-pro (people pay me to play sometimes) musician. After playing rock, blues, R&B, & pop in bands & 1 duo, my musical act since COVID, Jaz Dumoz, is struggling to find an audience. I'm playing pop tunes, mostly 1920-1940s, but, as pop tunes, not as jazz. I am not a jazz musician, I am not particularly a fan. So, the act is totally unique, maybe because, it doesn't work?

   In 2024, I had 0 paying gigs, 1st year since 2005, so my musician status lapsed to "amateur". I did have a gig this year, phew, back to semi-pro! But, losing interest in gigging, I enjoy more working up & recording old tunes - currently 205 on the @JazDumoz YouTube channel.

5. Birding, maybe a couple of decades now, as mentioned above. This year I've got moving the eBird data into a relational database (SQLLite) & doing more year-to-year analysis on my list.

I never dreamed that my 6th & possibly last area of interest would be ... Bullshit.

---

It started with my initial generative "AI" rant "Bullshit All The Way Down", which is now a homepage for the currently 6 posts I have written on this topic. This led me to realize that Bullshit in general pervades our modern society and should be a pressing topic of research. Generative "AI" aka Bullshit Generators will be a large contributor to the coming Bullshit Apocalypse, but there are many other forms of Bullshit that will also do their part.

I have read Harry Frankfurt's "On Bullshit", review coming shortly, and have a few other short books on the topic on my iPad. And I have started a post "A Taxonomy of Bullshit", to try and enumerate the many ways Bullshit is infiltrating everything. This post was the intro to that post, I have broken it out here so that that post can focus on Bullshit and the coming Bullshit Apocalypse. Watch this space.

Picks and Shovels

"Picks and Shovels", by Cory Doctorow, 2025, 419 pages, 129k words.

The 3rd (and final?) Martin Hench novel. These have been told in reverse chronological order.

Here's my post on the 1st "Red Team Blues".

Here's my post on the 2nd "The Bezzle".

This installment is the secret origin story of our superhero forensic accountant. Martin Hench is entering MIT in 1979 as a 17 YO freshman (11 years after I did). He's supposed to follow his dad as an engineer, but once he encounters computing, he is hooked. He winds up in early Silicon Valley on the west coast, where he helps an unlikely group of founders fighting a totally crappy, abusive, lockin computer company. Lots of action, but, the characters are what make the book. They all have so much heart.

I was working for DEC (mentioned) 1977-1980 installing & programming PDP-11s (mentioned), hooking up Okidata printers (mentioned), twiddling pins on RS-232 connectors (mentioned). So lots of old memories for me.

It's definitely a page turner, I was up til 1am finishing it, I very rarely do that anymore. Doctorow continues to be the Bard of the Revolution.

The Birth of Capitalism - or Not ...

I wrote this in May, 2024. The main theme of the post - identifying the birth of capitalism - kind of fell apart at the end. I meant to get around to revisiting it, but never did.

I'm going to go on and publish, I think there are good points in here. Particularly, the Chinese fleets visiting India & East Africa around 1000 AD and mostly leaving behind gifts, vs. the Portugese under the butcher Vasco da Gama visiting India 500 years later & committing PTSD level acts of barbarism.

It really makes me wonder, does enough of that history still underpin the culture of China, such that China as the new world hegemon would actually be a really good thing?

[Originally written 2024-05-15.]

So, the cliché of the out-of-control AI who turns the entire world into paperclips? It is here and now, approaching its 250th birthday: capitalism, which is well on its way to successfully turning the entire world into capital. "When capitalism started, we had plenty of nature but very little capital. Now, we are awash in capital but running out of nature (resources)."

That quote was me remembering Peter Barnes, "Capitalism 3.0". Here's what he actually said:

Is capitalism a brilliant solution to the problem of scarcity, or is it itself modernity’s central problem?
...
When capitalism started, nature was abundant and capital was scarce; it thus made sense to reward capital above all else. Today we’re awash in capital and literally running out of nature.

Capitalism is a virulent cancer that has infected our civilization and our planet. A pessimist would surely say neither will survive. Civilization crashes, and the Earth becomes Venus. Au revoir a tout les chose nous aimons. Au revoir a tout. Goodbye to everything we love. Goodbye to everything.

[Actually, civilization crashing might keep Earth from becoming Venus. Yay!?!?!?]

[After a climate crisis (1000 years ago?), the large North American indigenous populations decided to decentralize and deemphasize cities so as to ??? lower their environmental impact and resource requirements???]

[Venus === "mean temperature of 737 K (464 °C; 867 °F) and a pressure of 92 times that of Earth's at sea level".

I recently read an article saying that, once the tipping points had tipped, it would only take 300-400 years for the Earth to turn into a twin of Venus.]

But, thinking back to "Debt: the 1st 5000 Years", the rapacious behavior that characterizes capitalism started with the "Age of the Great Capitalist Empires (1450 - 1971)". The behavior of the Portuguese in the Indian Ocean and India, once they found their way there, was so abhorrent and revulsive. And once it got started, it was almost as if the European colonizers - Britain, France, Netherlands, Spain, Portugal, Belgium, Germany - were in a competition to see who could behave the worst.

Seriously, read the Wikipedia article on Vasco de Gama, acclaimed Portuguese explorer. It's horrifying - absolutely no joke, PTSD warning ...

500 years earlier, Chinese ships had found their way to India, the Indian Ocean, and Africa. They left lots of gifts behind. No piracy. No blockades. No sending basketsful of the hands and feet of hostages back to the hostages' families.

The Bard of the Revolution, my hero, Cory Doctorow has characterized the "out-of-control AI who turns the entire world into paperclips" as the LLC, the Limited Liability Corporation. A more specific identification than mine, of "capitalism". And, indeed, "Debt", identifies the driving force of the "Age of the Great Capitalist Empires" as the corporations, the 1st of which were the British East India company & others, if I remember right.

I think this is leading me to conclude that I am incorrectly identifying the Birth of Capitalism as "Wealth of Nations", 1776. Based on "Debt", maybe we should identify the Birth of Capitalism as 1498, when the Portuguese discovered the route to India, starting 5 centuries of European Colonialism raping & pillaging of the rest of the world. 5 centuries! Capitalism is 526 YO, FTW, FTL!!

TODO:

1. Eat the rich, before they eat us.

2. Kill capitalism, before it kills us.

[Afterthought]

Maybe a better starting date: the year of the incorporation of the British East India Company, or whichever corporate AI* was 1st. OK, checked this out, East India Company was incorporated 1600, Dutch version 1602. So, I think the attribution of the Birth of Capitalism to 1498, when the Portuguese started trade wars with India, is a OK year for the Birth of Capitalism.

Reading the article on Vasco da Gama, his expeditions seemed to have been backed by the Portuguese royality, not a corporation. The more I think about it, the more da Gama seems to be be pre-Capitalism.

1498 is the year of the Birth of European Colonialism. I think I will leave the year of the Birth of Capitalism as a matter still under study.

[*I believe it is appropriate to speak of all corporations as AIs. Computers nonwithstanding, corporations are group intelligences, with humans as their gut flora & maybe memes. And it is terrifying that for the most part their only real operating directive is: "make money; turn a profit".]

The Best Science Fiction of the Year Volume 6

"The Best Science Fiction of the Year Volume 6" edited by Neil Clarke, 2021, 816 pages, 253k words, 32 stories: 17 short stories (< 7500 words), 15 novelettes (< 17500 words), 0 novellas (< 40000 words).

This volume covers 2020, the year of COVID. Apparently a LOT more people wrote & submitted short stories to be published. The collection has an increasingly foreign flavor - a good thing IMO.

There are a number of climate fiction stories. I'm sure that this number will continue to grow.

---

The 1st story "Scar Tissue" is by Tobias S. Bucknell, whom I reliably enjoy. He will always have a soft spot in my heart, because after reading & liking some of his stuff, I could not find eBooks for the early trilogy he did. I emailed him & asked if he knew where I could find it. He emails me back the ePubs of the 3 novels. I love living in the future!

This story completely implements an idea about AI that I have had for decades - that for an AI of human capabilities, you must raise it as if it were your child.

---

The Ray Nayler story "Eyes of the Forest" depicts an interesting ecology. Another soft spot, due to Nayler's novel which featured intelligent octopuses.

---

The Carrie Vaughn story "Sinew and Steel and What They Told" I think I had read before. It is a good old-time sci-fi story, reminded me, say, of "Slan" by A.E. Van Vogt, maybe.

---

The story "An Important Failure" by Canadian Rebecca Campbell is an absolutely fabulous story of climate fiction. A violin maker stives over decades to find the now mostly vanished woods to make a violin suitable for a young virtuoso. It is really well written.

---

"The Bahrain Underground Bazaar", by Nadia Afifi was very well written. As an old person, I appreciated this thoughtful story about an old person considering their death.

---

The James Patrick Kelly story, "Your Boyfriend Experience" was a fun story, with some interesting concepts re human-like androids. Extra points for the protagonist being a foodie.

---

"Beyond The Tattered Veil" by Mercurio D. Rivera was a great story. A very nice examination of the "we're living in a simulated universe" concept.

---

The Carolyn Ives Gilman story, "Exile's End", I had read before. It is a well-executed page-turner, but the basic premise of the story I found off-putting.

---

"Invisible People", by Nancy Kress. I'm reading this story & I'm like "Wow, a Nancy Kress story, & it's not too bad!" Famous last words. I'll go on & SPOILER ALERT this story, maybe you can skip it of you read the collection.

The Bronze Rule is: "Don't Be An Asshole". Libertarianism shares with MAGAtism either a disregard for this rule - "It's OK to be an asshole." or, an actual espousal of the anti-bronze rule: "Be an asshole whenever possible."

So some oligarch decides to genetically engineer children to be altruistic. After this gets found out, the adopted parents of one of these children, 9 years old, decide to have their child undergo an experimental treatment to reverse the genetic changes. That is how the story ends.

There was also a scene where the altruistic child takes toys to a homeless camp, after news reports that the children had no toys, & is being threatened by a drunk homeless man. Her 18 YO babysitter pulls out a handgun & fires a warning shot in the air! And the parents' response: "You better have a permit for that!" Ugh, ugh, ugh. Handguns kill far more children than homeless people do.

Kress was born in 1948, so she was maybe 72 when the story came out? Another scared, selfish old white woman. Sad.

---

"Textbooks In the Attic", by S. B. Divya, is a well-paced climate fiction story.

---

"Seeding the Mountain", by M. L. Clark, is another, longer climate fiction story, this time set in Columbia, with nano-tech and pandemic elements. Several moving parts come together nicely in the end.

---

"Knock Knock Said the Ship" by Rati Mehrotra was a fun space pirate story set in a solar system at about the same level of development as The Expanse.

---

"Tunnels", by Eleanor Aranson was a fun story of corporate intrigue & film-making. You have to love a story where 1 of the main heros is the last crab-like body - normally they have 8 bodies - of an alien whose superpower is accounting & auditing.

We are the best players of capitalism in the known galaxy.

Aranson was born in 1942, her Wikipedia page makes her sound pretty woke. So not all old people write libertarian drivel, yay! I have her last novel, "Woman of the Iron People", 1991, on my iPad, I may have to get around to reading it ...

---

"Test 4 Echo", by Peter Watts. Holy crap, what a great story! It reminded me of his incredible novel "Blindsight", blogged here, for the creativity and originality with which he riffs on intelligence, consciousness, etc. - via NSAs - Neuromorphic Sapient Artefacts.

---

The Ken Liu story, "Uma" is tight, well-constructed, and a great read. Liu is 1 of our best sci-fi writers now IMO. A UMA is a Utility Maintenace Avatar, BTW.

---

"The Translator, At Low Tide" by Vajra Chandrasekera, is another climate fiction story. It is very well written, but very grim, morose, depressing even.

---

"Salvage" by Andy Dudak was a great story. An interesting cosmology - have I encountered it before? - and a nicely flawed heroine.

---

And finally, "How Quini the Squid Misplaced His Klobučar" by Rich Larson. I had read this before, I'm guessing in the tor.com blog when it came out, or in the annual recap they do of the original short stories they publish there. Larson is definitely the most viscreral writer I've read lately. This story reminds me a lot of the run of Case at the end of "Neuromancer".

The main hacker character is male transitioning to female, as was Violet, the main character of "Annex", blogged here. I mentioned in that post that despite there being an excerpt from "Cypher - Book Two of the Violet Wars" at the end of "Annex" - Book One of the Violet Wars - "Cypher" does not seem to have materialized. Every online site talking about Larson has the same blurbs with no recent info. As I said before, I hope Larson is doing OK.

---

This was a strong collection. I think Clarke is proving to be a good successor to Dozois.

I have several good novels waiting, plus I need to further my explorations into the wonderful world of bullshit.