1st up, someone whom I have not heard comment on GenAI before: Claudia Sahm, an economist I believe is considered an expert on identifying recessions. From her SubStack, Stay-At-Home Macro (SAHM).
Ode to the JuniorsShe later quotes Furman.AI can do the tasks. The mission still needs people, especially young ones.
AI is coming for the economics profession itself. The debate lands differently when you hear your job, or the job that started your career, described as replaceable by AI.
That was my experience a few weeks ago when I read an interview with Jason Furman. He argued that current AI models could replace most of the economic staff he had at the Council of Economic Advisers. I worked as a senior economist at CEA, on detail from the Fed, for Furman in 2015-16, so that got my attention. His suggestion that CEA’s junior staff, in particular, should be replaced was even more troubling. Juniors at CEA, like research assistants or pre-docs elsewhere, are the profession’s pipeline. My research assistant job at Brookings was my first step to becoming an economist.
Some of the AI-generated papers, blogs and briefings are cutting-edge. Some need significant work and have big deficiencies that need to be remedied by humans. And some of the longer papers might even be garbage.So this is clearly reverse centaur mode GenAI use - humans handed AI slop & told to clean it up - rather than centaur mode - skilled knowledgable humans using GenAI as a tool. Why would this guy think this is a good idea?
Sahm notes that in a follow-up paper, Furman backs off a little. But her point is, replacing entry level economists with GenAI is eating the seed corn - a bad idea. We've seen this before, & we'll see it again in the last article of this post.
Next, from software pioneer Jaron Lanier in the New York Times.
I Am a Silicon Valley Pioneer. We Are Sabotaging Ourselves.Hmmm, so, no thinking of GenAI as a talking dog?!?!?...
I have been discussing A.I. with some of its founding fathers for decades. In the 1980s, I think I coined the phrase “tools not creatures” in one of the arguments I had with my mentor Marvin Minsky, the MIT professor who was instrumental in shaping A.I. culture. Since there is no definitive evidence proving that A.I. is a conscious entity, the phrase means that I am entirely within my rights — as is anyone else within theirs — to think of the technology as more akin to a fancy calculator than, say, a German shepherd. That choice helps us design more useful products. And, as we’ll see, it provides a concrete and achievable way to make A.I. safe.
Lanier posits that the GenAI companies make these alarming statements about AI wiping out the human race are religious in nature?!?!? They are totally drinking the koolaid, believing that AI will not only become conscious, but godlike!
I'm more of the mind that the alarmism is just marketing hype to drive up company valuations. & Lanier I think somewhat validates this viewpoint. Going back to the early-1980s, working at MIT under Minsky, pitching to the DoD:
Advertising the end of humanity has been a moneymaker for us in computer science forever, and over time, some of us began to believe the pitch.Lanier feels LLM Agents are bad tech. He has a different, very centaur-like process for using LLMs.
I think his overall take is quite unique, seasoned by his decades in the field. This article is totally worth the read.
From 404 Media.
'Reverse Engineer Anything': AI Companies Crack Down on the Coolest Thing People Were Doing With AIJust last month we learned about the 'Reverse Engineer Anything' use of GenAI. The 2nd article of the linked post.The future of hacking your devices is in local and open-weight AI.
This is something that might actually empower people against corporate IP tyranny. So of course the big language models are putting up guardrails (hackable, I'm sure) to prevent it. Hence the authors' recommendation of "local and open-weight AI".
From the ever-sane & reliable AI As Normal Technology.
The missing quadrant in responses to AII'm getting a little disappointed in these guys. In their 4th theses they reference "alignment" - which is completely non-existent in the framework of LLM-based technology IMO.Announcing STABL: Societal Transformation and AI Bottlenecks Lab
We are starting a non-profit research organization: STABL.
Adapting to advanced AI will require dramatic institutional change and broad societal resilience. It will also require evidence about AI progress and impacts — the prospects of recursive self-improvement (RSI), the pace of AI diffusion, and the bottlenecks that constrain how AI capabilities translate into societal outcomes.
Four theses define our worldview:
- We consider advanced AI a transformative general-purpose technology with the potential for broad societal benefits.
- Yet we recognize that the pace of societal transformation will be bottlenecked by the speed of human and organizational change more than progress in capabilities.
- Our institutions — the established ways we organize knowledge, work, and governance — are an important source of stability during this turbulent period, but they also need serious reforms to keep serving their purpose.
- We favor a broad portfolio of defenses to manage AI risks, of which alignment is only one part. Resilience, the most neglected component today, must become central.
They define 2 axes: x is "the importance of downstream bottlenecks"; y is "AI's transformative potential", and superimpose 4 quadrants. Did anyone else ever use quadrants besides Gartner's "Magic Quadrants"? I always found those simplistic & cheesy.
They then explore "4 key research directions" & plug them into their quadrant system.
I think last Bullshit Apocalypse post, I formulated an heuristic that anybody who indicates that RSI - recursive self-improvement - is plausible, or, even worse, inevitable, is drinking the koolaid. I think our guys here are definitely drinking the koolaid.
From our thought leader Gary Marcus.
Breaking: Eli Lilly CEO becomes latest to push back on Dario Amodei’s ludicrous, Elizabeth Holmes-like medical claimsI had to lookup Nathan Fielder. He directed the just-released documentary "You Can See Everything", about medical fraudster Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos.Where is Nathan Fielder when you need him?
Wow, they seemed like they were getting better, but Anthropic must be freaking out as their IPO appears to be going into crash-and-burn mode. Hence their CEO's ourrageous claims.
Cancer, Alzheimer’s, heart disease, mental illness - these will be relics of the past in, I think, less than a decade.Man, Marcus's post features a veritable horde of people piling on in calling bullshit on this bullshit.
Finally, from Canadian sci-fi author & futurist Karl Schroeder, in his Unapocalyptic blog.
After Enshittification - 1: The System Eats Itself"The System Eats Itself" is I think the same as "eating the seed corn" we saw in the 1st article of this post. It is interesting that Schroeder identifies this as a form of Doctorow's enshittifcation. He also gets Marx involved.Replacing you with a more-efficient AI won’t save your company. Real-world systems rely on inefficiencies as ‘batteries’ that make them more resilient to change
An unsettling idea is starting to emerge here. When the system eats itself, it isn’t necessarily greed, short-term thinking, or corporate one-upmanship that’s caused it. Is it, as Marx said, because all capitalist companies are driven by competition?I like how he closes. I would equate his "individuality" with "personality", as I discussed here with its enemy, GenAI-driven semantic ablation....
The problem is efficiency itself.
AI can replace general skills, knowledge, and speed for any given role. The one thing it can’t be is particular. This is important because there’s no such thing as a company-in-general. There are only particular companies. That’s what it means to be real: that you are an individual, not an abstraction.Like the Lanier article, this one has a different, unique viewpoint & is definitely worth a read.The smart move is to keep hiring people even though your new employees aren’t nearly as ‘productive’ as the AIs. You’re not hiring them to be productive. On the one hand, you’re hiring them to provide a stock of requisite variety that can keep the firm viable as the environment it swims in changes. But you’re also hiring them because they are actual people—because they provide another stock that is absolutely essential for a real company to survive:
Individuality.
Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit. This is post #163.
No comments:
Post a Comment