Thursday, November 12, 2026

Code and Codex

"Code and Codex", by Yoon Ha Lee, 2026, 304 pages, 82k words.

I disliked this book to the extent that I wasn't going to include the cover or a link. But I decided, I'd stick with the format because, whatever.

The best thing about this novel is that it wasn't very long, only 84k words, whew.

The worst things about this novel? Where to begin? Pretentious. Incoherent. Stupid. Completely unlikeable characters. Really only 4 humans, plus 2 AIs. The humans are all having sex with each other. Completely unbelievable world-building, including sumptuary laws for the commoners.

In some ways, this was a novel for GenAI times. The galactic empire's power is based on a magical language. Books & language are everything - just what the GenAI backers are saying about why LLMs will rule the world. Ugh.

An LLM may actually good at counting the number of non sequiturs in this novel. That would be an interesting stat: non sequiturs / page. This novel would prolly be off the charts.

Lots of new words, both from music & linguistics, some of them made up. Normally a feature, here it just contributes to the pretentiousness. Plus references to semiotics AND semiology - 2 words for the same thing, you think they would pick 1, but, why make things less confusing? References to semiotics are always a warning sign, bullshit ahead.

like lost-wax casting in the metallurgy of semiotics.
Seriously? What is that supposed to mean?

More WTFs.

  • Ink of carnality causes human spontaneous combustion in combination with several rare venereal diseases.
  • Why didn’t the sign language align neatly with the spoken and written languages, especially on matters as crucial as honorifics?
  • The bindery had incorporated metal forged from melted-down trumpets and treasonous mortars.
  • They passed displays of swords so ancient that only cobwebs of speculative metallurgical scholarship held them together.
  • Perhaps, in some other world, all stars were fish, or all fish were stars, and sashimi was a specialty reserved for cannibal gods.
  • Sometimes it was as light as a gull’s feather, sometimes as heavy as hemorrhage.
  • I glutted myself on the local tickling flavors of half-life hedonism, twice-used syringes, mushrooms fed on afterbirth. I’m not picky.
I thought I had liked this author's 1st trilogy. I had purchased it after really liking 1 of their short stories in 1 of Clarke's "Years Best" collections. I just looked at my review of that trilogy - I wish I had done that before I prioritized reading this new novel.
I stayed fairly engaged going through the 3, but at the end, I was really unsure if these were worth the time invested.
They were 99k, 111k, & 126k words. 2, 1, & 1 big events. As I said at least this 1 was shorter.

1 last thing, 90% of the way through this novel, looking like we're heading for a conclusion, there is suddenly quite a few pages of totally gratuitous back story?!?!? The plotting of all these novels is plodding & eneven.

I think I've vented enough. Just say no.

No comments: