Oct 24, from Gary Marcus.
Will Generative AI do more harm than good?I think that I would agree with the premise of this title - definitely more harm than good.Things aren’t looking great.
But, it doesn't matter if it does more harm than good, because techbros & speculators are going to make $$$$$$$$$$$ off of this, so fuck the rest of us.
Plus, how do you force a genie back into its bottle? Even if it's a genie whose top use case is as a sledgehammer for hackers.
Very hard stuff. At some levels, information does want to be free.
October 26, from 404 Media. Gawd, this is pathetic. The never-to-be-even-vaguely-profitable AI Labs are pointing user requests for help & support at the media?!?!?
ChatGPT Keeps Telling People 404 Media Can Solve Their Tech Support ProblemsBecause big tech doesn't do customer service, we are being inundated with AI-generated emails begging us for help.
From the "How Things Work" SubStack of Hamilton Nolan.
Risk FactorsExcerpted from Anthropic's IPO filing S-1 document. 9 "risk factors". Every 1 of them is a totally cringe-worthy "oops". Oops?!?!?What Anthropic has to say for itself.
On a philosophical note, from the Programmable Mutter substack of Henry Farrell, October 29.
Agentic AI is myth set in motionThis is interesting. There have been a couple of posts in this series that explored, what is GenAI, actually? Their formulation recalls to mind the semioticians view of GenAI as a complete compilation of every word humans have written. Literary theory folks preach that nothing matters but words, &, goddamm, LLMs sure can do words, can't they?Modern AI is neither god nor mechanical bird. It is best understood as a technological version of the Homeric songs that inspired Alexander’s conquests, an epic grown so vast that it encompasses not just heroes, monsters and supernatural helpers, but enormous swathes of practical written knowledge, animated to make it capable both of narrating itself and acting out this narrative on the world that inspired it.
It seems to me that there should surely be a new name for GenAI to add to my table of names for GenAI in this article, but I did not find it in my 1st pass through. I will try again.
From The Algorithmic Bridge of Alberto Romero.
New Study: Anthropic Just Gave You a Reason to Stop Working With AIThis is textbook Semantic Ablation. This is the 11th post in this series tagged with Semantic Ablation.The machine is secretly making up your mind
This graph from the article illustrates Semantic Ablation perfectly.
"Pick a number between 1 and 10."
When I retired in 2012, I resolved I was going to study Economics. The 1st book I read on economics was "How Much Is Enough? Money and the Good Life", by the father/son philosopher/economist team of the Skidelsky's.
After defining Basic Goods, they define 7 Basic Goods that define The Good Life.
Here's Basic Good #4.
Personality. "The ability to frame and execute a plan of life reflective of one's taste, temperament and conception of the good." It would hard to conceive of any kind of Good Life that did not have rampant individuality, the more the better. It also implies the concept of private property.Semantic Ablation is an offense against Personality. It erodes personality. Do we really want a world where we all sound just like each other?
I've been writing this blog for 23 years (the LLM training bots love it!) If there were some person who had been consistently reading it, I think they would immediately recognize a post written by someone other than me. Crappy as it is, I have a style. Why would I ever want to sacrifice that to an LLM? What would the malevolent genie give me in return for sacrificing my personality?
But, I guess, increasingly people won't care about that. So what if my writing is indistinguishable from everyone else's? You know tho, maybe if it were just a matter of style, OK, maybe. But, it is actually also a matter of the content.
Finally, from the FRED (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis) blog. GenAI is apparently increasing productivity seriously in the Information sector of the economy. Yes, people who used to love software development now hate it & are leaving the field in droves, but, increased productivity!
Early signs of AI-driven productivity growth in the information sector?GenAI can be a great tool for software development. Unfortunate that, as an implication of this, it is also an incredible tool for hacking systems.
Here's the home page/directory for my posts on Bullshit. This is post #160.




